Product category:
Microprocessors, Microcontrollers and DSPs
News Release from: Broadcom Corp
Edited by the Electronicstalk Editorial
Team on 29 January 2007
Court clears Broadcom in compression
patent case
A federal jury in San Diego found that Broadcom Corp had not infringed two patents for digital video compression owned by Qualcomm.
A federal jury in San Diego found that Broadcom Corp had not infringed two patents for digital video compression owned by Qualcomm The nine member US District Court jury reached its unanimous verdict after six hours of deliberation, rejecting Qualcomm's claims of infringement following a nine day trial that included testimony from multiple experts as well as the companies' chairmen, Broadcom cofounder Dr Henry Samueli and Qualcomm cofounder Dr Irwin Jacobs
This article was originally published on Electronicstalk on 6 Jun 2008 at 8.00am (UK)
Related stories
Next generation Bluetooth enhances audio
The BCM2070 introduces new levels of performance for Bluetooth devices including the smallest available solution and a saving in power consumption of up to 40%.
Dual-band 802.11n radio comes in a single IC
Device will enable very small and cost-effective USB adapters that connect PCs, TVs, set-top boxes, personal video recorders and other devices to Wi-Fi networks.
In addition to finding the two patents not infringed, in an advisory opinion to the presiding judge the jury found that Broadcom proved by clear and convincing evidence that Qualcomm knowingly violated a duty to disclose its patents to the Joint Video Team, or its parent organisation, during the JVT's preparation and eventual adoption of the video compression industry standard known as the H.264 standard.
Additional evidence of Qualcomm's effort to unfairly leverage the H.264 standard emerged during trial, with testimony that the company requested a royalty for a single patent allegedly reading on H.264 that is twice the amount charged by the entire MPEG LA licensing organisation for its pool of 160 essential patents - and with Qualcomm's attempt to enjoin Broadcom's future sales of H.264-compliant products.
In a second advisory opinion to the judge, the jury found that Broadcom proved by clear and convincing evidence that Qualcomm committed inequitable conduct before the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) by breaching its duty of honesty and good faith in dealings with the USPTO.
Further reading
Speedy transceiver accelerates backplane comms
10GbE PHY support the IEEE 10GBase-KR standard for running 10Gbit/s serial data over backplane systems.
Set-top-box SoC aims for Chinese HD market
Designed for cable, satellite and IP set-top boxes, the new BCM7403 provides advanced PVR capabilities and advanced playback of content from nontraditional sources.
Set-top box SoC targets Chinese market
Multiformat high-definition video/audio SoC provides AVS support and advanced capabilities such as networked personal video recording.
"We are obviously very pleased and very grateful for this jury's diligence in working to arrive at the truth, even when presented with some very complex and intricate engineering testimony", said David A Dull, Broadcom's Senior Vice President and General Counsel.
"This is a victory not just for Broadcom but for the entire digital video community, against an attempt by Qualcomm once again to tax an important new technology - in this instance based on the claims of a single patent".
"The trial not only showed that Qualcomm was wrong about Broadcom's alleged infringement, but also cast a bright light on Qualcomm's penchant for abusing the rules and procedures of industry standards-making bodies".
The victory marks Broadcom's second consecutive win against Qualcomm involving intellectual property issues.
Last autumn, a United States International Trade Commission (ITC) judge ruled that Qualcomm's cellular baseband chips infringe five claims of a Broadcom patent.
The full commission affirmed that ruling in December and is now considering remedies against many Qualcomm products.
The ITC action was the first of several patent disputes between the companies to go to trial.
Broadcom is now in the final stages of preparing additional cases that go to the heart of its patent infringement disputes with Qualcomm concerning cellular baseband chips.
In March 2007, the US District Court in San Diego is scheduled to try Broadcom's claims that Qualcomm infringes two Broadcom patents relating to Bluetooth technology in cellular phones.
Then in May 2007, the US District Court in Santa Ana, California is scheduled to try Broadcom's claims that Qualcomm infringes three additional Broadcom patents relating to cellular technology.
Qualcomm and Broadcom have other, later-filed patent disputes pending in US District Court in San Diego that are also expected to be tried this year.
Following conclusion of the ITC proceeding, expected this March when the Commission is scheduled to rule on remedies for Qualcomm's infringement, Broadcom will also litigate in the Santa Ana court the same three patents that were tried last year in the ITC.
Altogether, Broadcom currently has infringement claims from 14 different Broadcom patents awaiting trial against Qualcomm.
• Broadcom Corp: contact details and other news
• Email this article to a colleague
• Register for the free Electronicstalk email newsletter
• Electronicstalk Home Page
Search the Pro-Talk network of sites
